Challenge of State Taxation Agencies
International Tax Consultant Yana Weaver – (714) 569-1000
What becomes increasingly challenging for foreign business entities because the triggers for taxation differ from state to state and often involve criteria not traditionally recognized in foreign countries. In most cases, being geographically based in a state places the company under that state’s tax jurisdiction. In recent years, more and more states have switched to the “economic nexus” concept, meaning the state will have the right to tax companies even without the company having a physical presence in that state. Doing business in a specific state and reaching a certain level of sales, even if the U.S. branch or affiliate of the foreign business entity does not have a physical location in that state, can result in placing them under the jurisdiction of that state’s taxation agency. While income tax treaties generally limit US federal income taxation of non-US corporations, these treaties do not apply for state income tax purposes. The provisions of these income tax treaties do not bind states. Therefore, foreign corporations can find themselves liable for state income taxes even though their income is subject to treaty benefits on the federal side. Also, some states determine state income tax liability by reference to the non-US company’s worldwide income, not just their US federal taxable income, and then calculate this liability by allocating a portion of the worldwide income to the state based on a formula. California is one of the “worldwide” states and has recently switched to an economic nexus model. California provides that an entity is considered to be doing business in the state if (among other factors) the entity sells to California customers over a certain threshold. As a result, the company can be required to file income tax returns in California and pay tax on the apportioned share of its income even without being physically present in the state.
